Think Again, Sovereignty by Stephen D. Krasner
Article SummaryThink Again: Sovereignty
By Stephen D. Krasner
Sovereignty is not Dead
For strong and weak states, sovereignty remains attractive.National borders and the erosion of national borders are the most concerning consequence of globalization
What does Sovereignty Actually Mean?
Hobbes and Bodin believed it was law and were concerned with maintaining domestic orderIn the modern world, sovereignty refers to independent and autonomous states
States can choose their own form of government within their borders
Non-intervention: States should not intervene in the internal affairs of another state
Technological change has made border control very difficult
Political leaders can enter into international agreements they find attractive
Treaties, as long as they are not coerced, are legitimate.
The Modern Sovereign State
1648 Peace of Westphalia ended the Thirty Years War against the Holy Roman EmpireIntroduced balance of power ideas
Was a new charter for the Holy Roman Empire
Established rules for religious tolerance
Major political leaders in Europe concluded that it was better to contain religious conflicts rather that repress differences
Challenges to Sovereignty
After WWII, human rights became the focus of attentionUN Charter endorses human rights issues but is nearly unenforceable and ineffective.
Globalization & Sovereignty
States are better equipped today to control the flow of ideas, information and goods than they were in the past.State control has increased in some areas and decreased in others
Religious tolerance, monetary policy, national citizenship- Decline in state control
Overall government activity has increased among the most advanced states
NGOs and Sovereignty
The number of transnational NGOs has grown immensely from the 1900s200 in 1909 to 17,000+ today
Technology has made it easier for NGOs to influence public policy and international law
Their ability to affect domestic affairs is limited
Sovereignty and Conflict Resolution
Conventional sovereignty rules make it harder to solve some problems- Israelis & Palestinians
- China & Tibet
- Hong Kong
The European Union
Is inconsistent with conventional sovereignty rulesMember states are intimately linked with one another
Member states have created institutions that can make decisions opposed by some member states
The EU is a product of state sovereignty because it was created by voluntary agreements among its member states but inherently contradicts the concept of sovereignty by undermining the individual sovereignty of its member states
More:
Conversations with History: Sovereignty with Stephen D. KrasnerYouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yapoX2hhRK4
UCTV: http://www.uctv.tv/shows/Sovereignty-with-Stephen-D-Krasner-Conversations-with-History-7882
Link to article: Think Again, Sovereignty
0 comments: